How Rahul Gandhi’s Parliament speech betrays misreading of Constitution and misunderstanding of governance

-

In his latest speech in Parliament, Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi said, among other things, that India is described in the Constitution as a “union of states” and not as a nation. There can be no quarrels with the first part of his assertion: Article 1(1) of the Constitution states precisely that. The first sub-clause reads: India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States.

What, however, did Rahul Gandhi mean when he also added that India is not a nation? He seemed to give some explanation by going on to say that someone from Tamil Nadu should have the same rights as someone from Maharashtra. This begs a question: If someone from Tamil Nadu should have the same rights as someone from Maharashtra, doesn’t that necessitate that India be a nation with some level of homogeneity?

And the fact that India is a nation is precisely what can be found in the very Constitution Rahul Gandhi referenced in his speech. The Preamble resolves to constitute India into a republic to secure to all its citizens fraternity, “assuring the dignity of the individual and the unity and integrity of the nation”.

So, did Rahul Gandhi stop reading the Constitution after the first sub-clause of the first Article? Because it speaks volumes that the vice-president (and former president) of a party credited with playing a major role in India’s national freedom struggle would contrive these distinctions.

And it isn’t that the Constitution of India does not acknowledge the fact that the Union consists of individual states. It purposefully gives states exclusive powers in several areas. Out of the three lists — the Union List, the State List and the Concurrent List — the second contains areas where only the states which form a part of our Union can legislate on, without interference from the Union.

As if that wasn’t enough, Rahul Gandhi, thereafter, went on to present another contrast to the Union of States principle enshrined in our Constitution. He insinuated that the current Modi government operates like a kingdom, imposing one homogenised view on the states which form our Union. That was a continuation of his apparent opposition to the idea of India being one nation.

What he fails to realise is that, in certain matters, the Union is required to step in to ensure homogeneity. His party has run governments for over six decades! The vice-president of the Congress party should have known better.

Only seven months ago, Rahul Gandhi’s party announced on its official Twitter handle that India is “one nation” with “one people” and, therefore, there should be “one price” for vaccination. It was attacking the Modi government for the fact that some states were required to pay a higher price for vaccines. And this price differential was because the Central government allowed states and private entities to buy vaccine doses directly from vaccine-makers. Yet, at that time, the Congress wanted homogeneity for India — “one nation” with “one people”.

And, moreover, the insinuation that the Modi government operates like a kingdom isn’t without its problems. One of the things Modi did within the first year of his tenure as India’s Prime Minister was to set up ‘Team India’ as a model of cooperative federalism to have an effective mechanism to resolve inter-state differences and chart a common course to progress and prosperity.

***

Also Read

How Rahul Gandhi has mastered the art of selective amnesia in his allegations against Narendra Modi govt in Parliament

Rahul Gandhi should have read BR Ambedkar more closely before making soft-secessionist statements in Parliament

Rahul Gandhi needs to be reminded of independent judicial system, EC was compromised during Congress regime

***

Even during the COVID-19 crisis, after the initial few months when the Centre took reins, it was pretty quickly left to the discretion of states to decide their own response and measures they deemed fit.

It’s not entirely clear why Rahul Gandhi brought up this distinction when his party’s own track record in stifling states is still fresh in many memories. Starting from the Emergency to imposition of President’s rule — the Congress government prior to Modi imposed it twelve times whereas the Modi government has only imposed it five times thus far.

He repeatedly mentioned Tamil Nadu in his rather angry and passionate attacks on the government. Is it that the developing politics in Tamil Nadu is making the Congress insecure? Is the party then, in response, dusting off an old trick in its playbook to see if it still works? The trick that the Britishers perfected to impact us till date – the trick of divide and rule?

Time alone shall tell.

The author is an immigration lawyer who writes on current affairs, law and politics. Views expressed are personal.

Read all the Latest News, Trending News, Cricket News, Bollywood News,
India News and Entertainment News here. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.



from Firstpost India Latest News https://ift.tt/7d3LKmt
Kartikeya Tanna

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Both COVID-19 vaccine doses needed for good protection against B16172 variant

-
It’s been a concerning few weeks in the UK, with the B16172 variant first taking hold and then spreading to become dominant. This more infectious form of the virus, initially identified in India, is what we’re now going to have to live with – unless it is out-competed by another variant in the future. Worryingly, experts had predicted that B16172 might be able to escape some of the effects of vaccines, which if true would threaten to derail the UK’s plans to finish lifting restrictions from the end of June. However, Public Health England (PHE) has looked at the ability of various variants to evade immunity and says that the UK’s vaccines remain effective against the variants circulating, including B16172. On the surface, this looks like good news. But delve a bit deeper, and things get more complicated, says Paul Hunter, professor of medicine at the University of East Anglia. PHE’s research found a little drop-off in protection against B16172 among people who were fully vaccinated.
Read more

New coronavirus variant emerge in India: How should our COVID response change?

-
Image
After genome sequencing of over 10,000 COVID-19 cases in India, researchers have discovered a new variant with two new mutations which may be better at evading the immune system. In 15-20 percent of samples from the Indian state of Maharashtra (the state accounting for 62 percent of cases in the country) a new, double mutation in key areas of the virus has been detected. These are now known as the E484Q and L452R mutations. What makes the variant different? Both these mutations are concerning because they are located in a key portion of the virus – the spike protein – that it uses to penetrate human cells. Spike proteins attach via a “receptor binding domain”, meaning the virus can attach to receptors in our cells. These new mutations include changes to the spike protein that make it a “better fit” for human cells. This means the virus can gain entry more easily and multiply faster. Given what we have seen with other similar mutations , it might also make it harder for our immu
Read more

120 flights delayed, 30 trains running late; Delhi fog & cold wave continue to give shiver to travellers

-
Arrival and departure of 120 flights, both domestic and international, to Delhi airport were affected due to dense fog and cold wave conditions on Wednesday, according to Delhi Airport FIDS (Flight Information Display System). As per the Delhi Airport FIDS, a total of 53 flights, including 21 domestic arrivals, 16 domestic departures, 13 international departures and three international arrivals scheduled are cancelled and not operating due to fog and other operational reasons from and to Indira Gandhi International (IGI) Airport in the national capital on 17 January. #WATCH | Delhi: Several flight operations delayed at IGI airport due to low visibility amid fog. pic.twitter.com/hG1DUKllEt — ANI (@ANI) January 17, 2024 Visuals from the Delhi airport showed passengers waiting outside, checking update of their scheduled flights. There were also some people waiting for flight of their families, friends and loved ones to arrive, which got delayed due to fog. #WATCH | Delhi | Pas
Read more